US organ donation system faces scrutiny and changes after reports of disturbing near-misses

Washington – The United States is developing new guarantees for the body transplanting system after a government survey has found a group of Kentucky, continuous preparations for organ donation by certain patients who showed signs of life, officials in Congress said on Tuesday.

While organ moves have been canceled, near the breaches that some legislators have called horribly should never occur. A subcommittee of the house asked how to repair confidence in the transplantation network for donors and families of potential bodies – some of which have withdrawn from donor registers after the publication of these cases.

“We have to do things well,” said Brett representative Guthrie, a Kentucky republican who chairs the energy and trade committee and whose mother died while waiting for hepatic transplantation.

“I hope that people will leave today knowing that we have to solve the problems, but always convinced that they can give life,” said Guthrie, adding that he will remain a recorded organ donor.

The hearing intervened after a federal investigation began last fall in allegations that a group of Kentucky donations put pressure on a hospital in 2021 to carry out plans to remove life and recover the organs of a man despite signs that he could wake up from his drug overdose. This surgery never took place after a doctor noticed him move and moan while being transported to the operating room – and the man survived.

The legislators have stressed that most of the organ donations take place appropriately and save tens of thousands of lives per year. But the federal survey – ended in March, but made public only before Tuesday’s hearing – cited a “risk model concerning” in dozens of other cases involving the initial planning of the Kentucky group to recover someone’s organs.

The report indicates that some should have been arrested or reassessed earlier, and mainly involved small or rural hospitals with less experience in the management of potential organ donors.

The Kentucky organ supply organization, or OPO, has made changes and the National Transplant Network works on additional steps. But in particular in the absence of Tuesday, any testimony of hospitals – whose doctors must determine independently that a patient died before the donation groups are allowed to recover the bodies.

Here is an overview of the operation of the nation’s transplant system.

More than 100,000 people appear on the list of American transplants and approximately 13 per day die pending, depending on the organ purchase network and transplantation.

Only about 1% of deaths occur in a way that even allows you to be considered as an organ donation. Most people declared dead in a hospital will be quickly transferred to a funeral home or a morgue.

Several groups are involved in each transplant: the hospital taking care of a dead or dying person; The 55 OPOs which coordinate the recovery of the organs and help make them match the patients on the waiting list; and transplantation centers that decide whether an organ is suitable for their patients.

Adding to complexity, two government agencies – HRSA, the Health Resources and Services Administration and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services – share the regulatory monitoring of different parts of the donation and transplantation process.

Most organ donors are dead from the brain – when the test determines that someone has no brain function after a catastrophic injury. The body is left on a fan to support the organs until they can be recovered.

But more and more organs are given after circulatory death, called DCD – when people die because their hearts stop. This usually happens when doctors determine that someone has a non -survival injury and the family withdraw support for life.

Hospitals are required to alert their OPO region to each potential donor who is declared death of the brain or once the decision to withdraw life is taken. OPO by law cannot participate in this decision and “we are not even in the room at that time,” said Barry Massa of Kentucky’s Network for Hope.

During the following days of preparation, hospital employees continue to take care of the patient – while the donation team speaks with the family family, collects hospital files showing that the patient is eligible, requests organ quality tests and make arrangements with transplantation centers to use them.

Once the hospital withdraws support from life and the heart stops beating, there is a compulsory wait – five minutes – to be sure that it will not restart. When the doctor declares death, the organ recovery process can start.

The organs are only considered usable if death occurs relatively quickly, generally up to about two hours. Sometimes it takes much more time and therefore the organs cannot be used – and Dr. Raymond Lynch of HRSA told Congress that it does not necessarily mean that something has been poorly done. However, he said that HRSA is investigating reports on possible errors elsewhere.

“This is a technically demanding form of care” which requires “good collaboration between OPO and the hospital,” he said.

The question is how doctors are sure when it is time to withdraw support for the life of a dying patient – and the delicate balance of the way OPO interact with hospital staff to prepare for a donation once the death is.

In May, HRSA discreetly ordered the American transplantation network to supervise improvements to Kentucky OPO and develop new national policies, which clearly shows that anyone – family staff, hospital staff or organ donation staff – may request a break in donation preparations at any time concerning the admissibility of the patient.

Lynch said that the government now wanted a more proactive collaboration for OPOs to give hospital staff “a clear understanding” to know at least temporarily to stop and reassess a potential donor if his state of health changes.

The Massa Kentucky said that his group had only received HRSA reports this week – but that after learning last fall allegations, this has made some changes. Massa has said that each doctor and nurse of the hospital now gets a control list on the management of potential donors and how to stop when concerns are raised – and anyone can report complaints anonymously.

___

The Department of Health and Sciences of the Associated Press receives the support of the Department of Science Education from Howard Hughes Medical Institute and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.