An Insurer Agreed To Cover Her Surgery. A Politician’s Nudge Got the Bills Paid.

For the most part, Keyanna Jones and her husband thought they knew what to expect when their daughter Chloë suffered an eye surgery last fall.

Even Chloë, who was in kindergarten, had a good understanding of how things would happen that day. Before the procedure, a hospital worker gave him a coloring book who explained the stages of surgery – a procedure to correct a condition that could ultimately have interfere with his vision.

“Chloë is very intelligent,” said Jones. “She reads at almost a third year level now, and she is only 6 years old.”

Jones also did his homework. Without pediatric ophthalmologists near their home in Wentzville, Missouri, who would take their insurance, she asked the insurer to cover the care out of Chloë as if it were a network. The insurer agreed to let it see an out -of -network specialist.

Chloë has achieved surgery without a hitch. Jones said her daughter had appreciated some iced lollipops in the hospital before going home.

“I slept with her every night because she was so worried that she wakes up and cannot see,” she said. “But that healed well, and she was absolutely ready to go back to school.”

Then the bill came.

Medical procedure

Chloë was born with a falling left eyelid, a condition known as Ptose. To correct the problem, an ophthalmologist surgically raises the eyelid, preventing it from disturbing the patient’s line of view.

Ophthalmologists, unlike optometrists and opticians, hold medical diplomas and can provide advanced eye care, including surgery.

The final invoice

$ 15,188, including $ 10,382 for the procedure and $ 2,730 for anesthesia. Initially, insurance paid only $ 1,775.79, leaving the Jones family from $ 13,412.21 – until the Chloë uncle, who had recently completed his mandate as a state senator, asked a colleague to examine him.

The problem: the approval of ghost insurance?

Months before the inhalation of anesthetic scented in Bubblegum at the Cardinal Glennon children’s hospital in St. Louis, Jones has discovered that it can be difficult to find a pediatric ophthalmologist. The doctor recommended by the Chloë pediatrician was not contracted with his insurer, Unitedhealthcare, and the nearest network specialist was in Wisconsin, hundreds of kilometers away.

Jones therefore asked what is called an exception of the network gap, under which the insurer would cover the services of the recommended doctor as a network.

Before surgery was provided, she received a letter indicating that Unitedhealthcare had approved her request “because there is currently no doctor, health professional or installation in your region to provide these services.” The letter has listed several medical billing codes for eye services and said they would be covered “at the network”.

About a week later, the insurer sent a previous letter of authorization approving Chloë surgery.

But Unitedhealthcare refused to pay most of the surgery bill, covering it as off -network. With letters of approval in hand, said Jones, she did not understand why the insurer apparently did not honor his agreement to cover the treatment of his daughter.

In fact, the letters of similar appearance have granted different types of approval.

The exception of Gap by Unitedhealthcare approved the Chloë exams before surgery as a network. But in his previous letter of authorization for his surgery with the same doctor, the insurer only said that she would cover him – without offering network discounts.

After receiving the bill, Jones contacted the online insurer, but said that a representative told her that there was no troop of his approval to cover surgery as a network.

“At that time, I didn’t even know what to do,” she said. “I say to myself:” It’s crazy. “”

She said that she had sent a copy of one of the letters of approval, which appeared on the company’s header paper, but a representative told her that the letter had not come from Unitedhealthcare.

“They said:” You saw this surgeon, they are not covered and you have not had permission, so no, we are not going to pay, “said Jones, telling the phone call.

An insurance representative told Jones that it owed more than $ 13,000 due to “a balance of balance bill”. This meant that the Jones family should pay the balance of $ 13,000 and more.

The spokesperson of Unitedhealthcare confirmed that the company had provided an exception of gap and a prior authorization for the care of Chloë. Eric Hausman, spokesperson for Unitedhealth Group, said in a statement to Kff Health News that “we sympathize with anyone who finds himself in the unhappy situation of being billed by an off-network supplier for a significantly higher amount of market rates, and without any prior knowledge.”

Maryanne Wallace, SSM Health spokesperson, the health system that includes the Cardinal Glennon children’s hospital, provided a statement that said that SSM has followed “standard patient billing procedures”.

“Sometimes an insurance company can deal with a complaint as an off -network service, which can lead to a balance billed to the patient,” the statement said.

Resolution

Jones said she was blinded by the big bill. She tried to solve the problem by herself, she said, keeping a trace of each interaction with the insurer and the hospital. She has submitted calls to Unitedhealthcare.

Nothing helped – until she contributes to her brother Caleb Rowden, who had been senator from the state of Missouri for eight years after having served four years at the State House.

“I have never used my brother’s political influence for anything,” she said. “I actually hate politics.”

Rowden told Kff Health News that he had contacted Travis Fitzwater, the state senator representing the district of his niece. Jones also contacted the Fitzwater office and sent a complaint to the Missouri general prosecutor Andrew Bailey.

Fitzwater said that his office was not doing more for Chloë than for any constituent.

“We are not going to take a lot of credit for the result, because we have only asked for a resolution, so that everyone can be at peace and move on,” he said in an interview. “We just did what we do every day.”

After the Fitzwater staff contacted the hospital and the insurer, representatives of the two called Jones separately and informed him that Unitedhealthcare had paid the entire invoice.

In the end, Chloë’s family has paid nothing for their procedure – not even a copying.

The point to take away

Regarding insurance approvals, carefully read the small characters; “Covered” does not mean that an insurer will pay, and even less at network rates.

Rowden and Fitzwater said that reaching out to the office of your elected representative can help. Advanced for voters is part of their work.

“They generally have an open communication line with these insurance companies and hospitals,” Rowden wrote in an email. “They cannot always achieve a positive result because each situation is a little different, but they can usually bring you to a next step.”

Jones is grateful that her brother was able to help, although she recognized that she probably wouldn’t have called her without a boost from their mother. “I think I would still fight,” she said.

The bill of the month is a survey on the crowdsourced of Kff Health News and the being well + of Washington Post which is disseminated and explains the medical invoices. Since 2018, this series has helped many patients and readers reduce their medical bills, and it has been cited in household houses, the American capitol and the White House. Do you have a confusing or scandalous medical bill you want to share? Tell us!

Kff Health News is a national editorial hall that produces in -depth journalism on health issues and is one of the main KFF operating programs – an independent source of independent research, survey and journalism. Learn more about KFF.

Use our contents

This story can be republished for free (details).