MLS 3.0? Why Major League Soccer’s new calendar is its smartest move in years

For once, Major League Soccer was right.

A league that barricades itself behind a pay-TV wall… constantly revises its playoff format… relies too heavily on foreign stars beyond its top stars… thumbs its nose at FIFA’s international windows… rejects the idea of ​​a promotion-relegation system… practically relies on the century-old domestic cup… valorizes artificial events during the regular season… and financially handcuffs its teams in perpetual continental failure…

Advertisement

Well, that same league made a smart decision on Thursday by changing its competition schedule.

For decades, MLS has rowed against the tide, starting the season at the start of the calendar year, playing through soccer-heavy summers and ending with the switching on of the Christmas lights.

However, from 2027, the 30-team circuit will align with most European leagues by running the season from mid-July to the end of May.

It’s a seismic decision, one that MLS executives and team owners weighed for years before finally reaching consensus Thursday at the Board of Governors meeting in South Florida. The last time they took such pronounced action was in 2007, instituting the designated player rule, a mechanism allowing teams to circumvent the salary cap and sign global superstars, such as David Beckham and Lionel Messi.

Advertisement

For a league with big ambitions but a history of confusing decisions, the schedule change had to happen. Ideally, it would have been passed before the World Cup in North America cast a huge shadow over the league next summer. But it will happen eventually. Good for MLS.

“Our owners are very committed to being one of the best leagues in the world, and being one of the few that isn’t aligned with the international calendar, we almost have an American exceptionalism, saying we’re going to play the game the way we want to play it, as opposed to the way the rest of the world plays it,” Commissioner Don Garber said.

It should be noted that not everyone follows the schedule that MLS will adapt; it’s primarily a way for MLS to align itself with Europe’s top leagues. But Garber’s point still stands: To take the next step in its carefully planned evolution, MLS must meet the best leagues where they are.

On the surface, this seems counterproductive. MLS will immerse the regular season deeper into direct competition with other sports leagues. Aside from a six-week winter break (for the regular season, but not necessarily all competitions), MLS will overlap with the entire NFL season and almost all NBA and NHL campaigns, as well as college football and basketball.

Advertisement

Currently, much of the MLS schedule takes place during lighter summers, competing with MLB, WNBA and NWSL.

Then there are weather considerations. With more games during the winter months, teams from cold-weather cities will have to play on the road immediately before and well after the winter break. (This year, the season started on February 22, but Montreal didn’t play its home opener until April 12.) Only about a dozen teams would be largely unaffected by the cold at home.

However, more games in winter mean fewer games in summer, when this year’s brutal heat caused regular water outages and intense thunderstorms forced many delays or postponements. Due to climate change, summers are neither getting cooler nor calmer. With the threat of discomfort and disruption at next year’s World Cup – as with last summer’s Club World Cup – FIFA will have to carefully select kick-off times in many cities.

The schedule change is actually not that drastic: MLS is swapping match days from around June 1 to July 15 for dates in early December and early February.

Advertisement

The new schedule will also provide a much better platform for the playoffs, which by definition should be the pinnacle of public interest. Instead, the MLS fall playoffs are falling off the radar amid NFL football and college football and the start of the NBA and NHL seasons. Additionally, MLS lost momentum by suspending the playoffs for two weeks in November to accommodate a FIFA international window.

And since the rights to host the championship are not pre-selected, MLS runs the risk of playing its first match in extreme conditions. (Kansas City and Toronto, in particular, hosted freezing finals.) In the spring, the weather is better, there are no soccer-related distractions, and no international windows to avoid.

This decision, however, was also driven by MLS’s need to join the greater soccer community. For starters, playing during the summer means scheduling conflicts almost every year with international tournaments, such as the World Cup, European Championship, Copa América and CONCACAF events.

MLS suspends its schedule only for part of the CONCACAF World Cup and Gold Cup, for example, leaving clubs without top players for weeks and forcing viewers to choose between league matches and international matches.

Advertisement

With an adjusted schedule, MLS would also have to stop scheduling regular season games, not only during parts of the busy summer, but also during the spring and early fall international windows.

From a player acquisition perspective, the MLS season will now align with international transfer windows in August and January. The offseason is a great time to acquire players, but the MLS offseason has fallen during the January window when there are fewer players on the market. As the summer window opens, most MLS teams have less roster and salary flexibility.

Summer is also the peak of overseas interest in MLS players, when European clubs add talent. With MLS no longer at mid-season, teams will be more willing to accept offers and, therefore, increase revenue from transfer fees – a vital part of running a successful club.

MLS is not the first to adjust its schedule. Japan’s J League, which is three years older than MLS, will also make the switch in 2027 with a winter break.

Advertisement

More than a decade ago, Russia, no stranger to harsh winters, also changed its calendar to conform with that of most European countries.

The MLS decision is not a panacea. The American league remains an adolescent in the global soccer landscape – sometimes acting like an adult but still displaying childish impulses. Big challenges prevent it from becoming as popular as other American sports leagues and matching the best soccer circuits in the world.

Changing the schedule is a step in the right direction, but to achieve its goals, MLS must continue to evolve. Thursday’s board meeting also involved discussions about changing roster rules, dropping conferences and adjusting the playoff format.

Advertisement

Garber says this is a move toward “MLS 3.0.”

He explained: “Now that we have established this great foundation, what do we need to do over the next 30 years to seize this great opportunity, to bottle all the enthusiasm and energy around our league and the growth of football on this continent and do it in a way that evolves and uses innovation and takes risks with the future in mind?

The schedule change was the league’s big event after years of stagnation. However, the next few moves will determine whether he sinks or swims.